Steve Bullock @GuitarMoog Immigrant, Musician, Sound Engineer, SNP, ex-negotiator for UK in EU. Brother of @JuliaKayPotts. Supporter of @FinalSayForAll. On Holiday. Back soon. Dec. 13, 2018 2 min read

My take on the EU Council after the conclusions and Press Conference (see below).

EU set out ready to give as warm, non-binding words as possible, but the PM's promises made in London, unfeasible asks, and unwillingness to face reality appear to have had the opposite effect. 1/

As Mark Stone points out, asking EU27 to trust her judgment at this stage will not have reassured anyone. She promised ERG legally binding reassurances that she was never, ever going to get. 2/

The PM apparently made proposals to lock EU27 into a future relationship that has not yet been negotiated, and to make the Political Declaration legally binding. Again, thinking either of these would fly hardly shows judgement. 3/

She agreed to the Withdrawal Agreement and assured EU27 she would get it ratified, and is now trying to re-open it because of how wrong she was. 4/

Their judgement appears to have been, rightly, that there was nothing they could give her that would reassure the DUP and ERG that the Backstop would, legally, be definitely temporary or unilaterally ended. Because it isn't, and it can't be. 5/

Add to this that they have watched the PM misrepresent the deal, their deal, still promising frictionless trade outside the Single Market and Customs Union and trumpeting an end to rights for their and her own citizens as an massive achievement. 6/

And that after two years of dishonesty, threats and insults from her, her ministers, and her parties' MPs, impossible and self-contradictory policies, no deal better than a bad deal rhetoric (and an unwillingness to rule out No deal now), using their citz as bargaining chips. 7/

So they do not and cannot trust her judgement, or trust her, her ministers, or her MPs. Goodwill and trust have evaporated. 8/

Had May taken a conciliatory, consensus seeking approach from the beginning, and managed expectations properly, she may now be in the situation where the only opposition to the deal were the handful of butters in the ERG, but it's too late to look for cross-party support now. 9/

This is a disaster for May, but it's a direct product of her and the rest of the Tory parties' approach and actions. 10/

The PM still has the time to avert No Deal and find a way out of this - an extension and a referendum looks most likely to do that to me - but it won't be by Parliament approving the deal, and there won't be another deal. 11/

She can decide to press on all the way to No Deal instead. But that will be a decision - her decision - to take the UK over an appalling cliff edge with nothing but chaos, impoverishment and misery at the bottom of the fall. 12/

Who knows if she would decide to do that, but Parliament and even her own Cabinet Ministers must act to make sure she doesn't. 13/

If they don't, and May does decide to take the UK over the No Deal cliff, her legacy will not be as the PM who delivered Brexit. It will be as the PM who decided appalling harm to her own country and population was worth it to do so. 14/14


You can follow @GuitarMoog.



Bookmark

____
Tip: mention @threader_app on a Twitter thread with the keyword “compile” to get a link to it.

Enjoy Threader? Sign up.

Threader is an independent project created by only two developers. The site gets 500,000+ visits a month and our iOS Twitter client was featured as an App of the Day by Apple. Running this space is expensive and time consuming. If you find Threader useful, please consider supporting us to make it a sustainable project.