(Thread) Traditional Conservatives and the Trump-Fox-GOP
A recent Vanity Fair article catalogues the GOP insiders who have enabled Trump, and offers their reasons/ rationale: Paul Ryan is an opportunist, McConnell is a cynic, Priebus is a stooge, etc.
1/ Another simpler way to say the same thing: These GOP leaders sold out to Trump because without America’s far right wing (white nationalists), the GOP wouldn't have been unable to put together national majorities.
2/ See this history of the GOP⤵️. After the 1960s, when the Democrats shifted its Confederate-era position and backed civil rights, traditional conservatives found themselves without a majority. To regain a majority, they adopted the Southern Strategy.
3/ In ⤵️ Paxton wrote that “the fascist route to power has always passed through cooperation with conservative elites, at least in the cases so far known. . .” p. 98
In the 1930, for example, “after Fascists and Nazis made themselves too important to ignore . . .
4/ “. . . the conservatives had to decide what to do with them.”
The conservatives had to “decide whether to try to co-opt fascism or force it back to the margins.” (p. 99)
Spoiler: Like the GOP, they tried to co-opt fascism.
5/ 20th century German and Italian conservatives decided to cooperate with the far right wing nationalists because the right wing nationalists "offered a new recipe for governing with popular support but without any sharing of power with the Left . . .” p. 104.
6/ From Profs. Ziblatt & Levitsky 👇 the GOP made the same mistake as the 20th century German conservatives: When Trump exhibited autocratic tendencies, they thought they'd remain in control and harness his popular appeal for their own benefit.
This is always a miscalculation.
7/ Important fact: Not all GOP "elites" enable Trump. An influential group of Never Trump conservatives include @MaxBoot, @BillKristol, @JRubinBlogger, @JustinAmash and others.
Remember also: psychologists distinguish conservatives from authoritarians👇
My mistake. I wrote too fast.
I also recall seeing a more recent similar article. They came together in my mind.
The points remain true, and more relevant as we move into the 2020 presidential election.
8/ Traditional conservatives with courage reject the Trump-GOP—and now they find themselves without a party.
Prof. Ziblatt and Levitsky in ⤵️ argue that for American democracy to recover and grow stronger, America needs a center-right party. (p. 224)
9/ Ziplatt and Levitsky acknowledge that refounding an American center-right party is a “tall order,” but they point out there are historical precedents, even under more challenging circumstances.
10/ For example, before 1940, Germany, never had a successful conservative party.
After 1945, Germany’s center-right party (the CDU) refounded itself and separated itself from extremists and authoritarians.
11/ For reasons explained by @JonHaidt here, a traditional conservative party provides a good balance for a more liberal party.
Center-right / traditional conservatives thus have a challenge: They must either recapture the GOP or found a new party.
12/ They must also way to pull together a coalition without the the far right wing nationalists.
Once they figure out how to do that, they'll help speed up America's recovery.
[I love twitter. If I make a mistake, I find out within 90 seconds 😍]
You can follow @Teri_Kanefield.
Tip: mention @threader_app on a Twitter thread with the keyword “compile” to get a link to it.
Enjoy Threader? Sign up.
Threader is an independent project created by only two developers. The site gets 500,000+ visits a month and our iOS Twitter client was featured as an App of the Day by Apple. Running this space is expensive and time consuming. If you find Threader useful, please consider supporting us to make it a sustainable project.